|
Maybe that's why the disaster happenned.Lord doesn't do anything to clarify the 'why', only the 'who'. The construction of the Titanic is described as 'watertight compartments'. There's no mention of why he was running full steam through an icefield, despite half a dozen radio warnings concerning ice in the area. There were watertight bulkheads between compartments, essentially dams until the water level rose higher than the top of each bulkhead. Extremely light on technical detail, it has almost no information about the building of the Titanic, or about the hearings held after the sinking.
Maybe the captain believed that 'watertight' description was accurate, and didn't bother to look himself. Incidentally, Lord's description would lead you to believe the Captain was chosen because of his popularity, not ability, and he bears no blame because the rich people liked his affable personality. Lord takes great pains to avoid offending the reputation of anyone on the ship, including the captain, the designers, and the builders of the Titanic, even though their collective and individual negligence was responsible for the disaster. This book comes across like a listing out of Who's Who of the era. The captain is portrayed as a stalwart, steady individual, though he was ultimately the individual most responsible for the sinking and deaths of quite a number of people.
No, they were *not* watertight, or the ship wouldn't have sunk.
He had referred to sources like magazines that had considered the ship unsinkable and he had many quotes from the crew and passengers aboard the ship. One of my favorites is when someone asked if the ship was really unsinkable one of the crew members said "Even God himself could not sink this ship". I think one of the problems for me was that it seemed like more of a list. One of the officers even said "Even God himself could not sink this ship." So everybody was positive that the boat could not sink, because of this they were unprepared if the ship did sink. One way is Captain Smith has a boat so Tobias could ride up the Kissimmee River to trade.
Theme ApplicationOne theme of this book is that the crew did not prepare the boat for the correct amount of people going on the Titanic's maiden voyage. Character ComparisonTobias McIvey(from Land Remembered) and Captain Smith could help each other. No because I found it hard to get interested in the book. Yes because it is extremely vivid. He also told the reader just about everything that happened even down to when they shot the flares up and how many lifeboats there were and how many people they could hold. Another thing the author put in the book was a labeled map and timeline of the ship. I think these two people would get along because Tobias is a very nice person and I think the relationship between them would be a lot like Tobias and Skillet's (former slave from Land Remembered) relationship. Someone who would like this book is someone who likes history or someone who enjoys reading about history.
RecommendationWould I recommend this book to others. Also to never say never and always expect the unexpected. Yes and no. There were sixteen life boats on the Titanic, all together the life boats could hold 1,178 people, on that Sunday night there were 2,207 people onboard the Titanic. Considering that there were 2,207 people on the Titanic's trip. There were obviously not enough life boats for all guests on the ship.
One reason they did not bring enough life boats was because everybody insisted that the ship was unsinkable. One example of this is that they only brought enough life boats for 1,178 people. One example of them not being prepared is the lifeboats. Captain Smith thinks everything will be ok, like Tobias, but Captain Smith knows when something is not right or when he shouldn't do something. This was very helpful because he talks about certain thing that happen in specific rooms so it helps you see exactly what flooded first and when they flooded. Almost as if it was too vivid or had too much description.
Something I have learned from this situation is to always bring enough or more than needed. Major ConflictThe biggest conflict in the book was that the Titanic was considered unsinkable by "Shipbuilder Magazine" and many other people and sources. Jacket BlurbThe author did fantastic job on writing this book. A list of like what people wore and what people did.
This book deserves two thumbs up just for the amazing detail. They would be able to help each other out because both are quick on their feet and both are very clever. The Carpathia was the first ship to arrive on scene of where thr Titanic had sunk. If your into non-fiction books this is the for you. For example the Titanic was supposed to be unsinkable but it sank on the first voyage. Although many lives were lost some were saved by the Carpathia. The story has a few climaxes and conflicts but I think the best one is when the Titanic started to sink.
Walter Lord makes you feel like your right there when all the action is taking place. You can really tell Walter Lord did tons of research, and it really shows. Walter Lord really out did himself with this book.I would recommend this book to anyone any day. "A Night To Remember" is very understandable so people of all ages will be able to read it and comprehend what they read.I think the theme of the story is don't be to sure of yourself. The only problem is Gabriel is a lot younger than Captain Smith.Walter Lord made "A Night To Remember" extremely suspenseful. It would be a great book for children to read because its not to long and the words aren't to big. I can apply this theme to real life by not trying to out do myself.
The statistics will just take your breath away and leave you speechless.
The Titanic had very high losses of lives because of the simple little fact that the Titanic only had enough life boats for half the people on board.
Thankfully for the survivors of the Titanic the Carpathia was prepared to save their lives.I would compare Captain Smith to Gabriel in "Gabriel's Horses".
Incredible details, for example the book tells the exact time things were happening.
I hope Walter Lord creates another book like "A Night To Remember".
Also I can apply this theme by just being happy with what I have.
One major conflict in "A Night To Remember" is when the Titanic and all its passengers and cargo started to sink.
These two characters would get along great because both have a passion for what they do and they're both determined at what they do.
It is very educational, and jammed pack full of facts.
Now I discuss the long-ago event with a grandson and discussed some of the things in the book.R.McMillenMassillon, Oh I set out a while ago to try to find the book. Out of 2200+ people, so many were lost - and recorded in this book by name. It arrived in a timely manner and in very good shape. I remember reading this book when I was a teenager. My mother had it (can't find it anymore) - and I recall being struck by the personal nature of this monumental news item, occurring many years before I was even born. I was pleased to have found it through Amazon.
Sometimes, the language is needlessly dense which caused obfuscation of the events. But somehow, several of the details in A Night to Remember are either murky or absent. All in all, there has to be a much better book than A Night to Remember. A Night to Remember is my first book about the Titanic, and I must say that I didn't really learn very much what I had already seen on the movie. Surely, the book offers a much more dramatic account of how it had happened. The later chapters are much worse especially after the Titanic sank.
|
